Novated Lease vs Car Loan Calculator

A novated lease pays for the car from your pre-tax salary, which can beat a car loan — especially for EVs, which are exempt from fringe benefits tax. This calculator compares the two honestly.

Lease rates typically run higher than loans
Fuel/charging, rego, insurance, servicing, tyres
Cheaper option over the term

Simplified model: ECM (employee contribution method) used for petrol cars to offset FBT; residual per ATO minimums; GST saved on the car price (up to the input tax credit limit) and on running costs under the lease. Get a formal quote before signing — packaging fees vary widely.

Uses official 2026-27 rates (last reviewed July 2026). Estimates only — see assumptions below.

How a novated lease works

Your employer deducts the car's finance and running costs from your salary and pays a leasing company — a three-way ("novated") agreement. Money that would have been taxed at your marginal rate instead buys the car, and the leasing company claims back GST on the purchase price and running costs. The tax system claws some back through fringe benefits tax — and managing that FBT is where the whole game is decided.

Why EVs changed everything

Since 2022, electric vehicles under the luxury car tax threshold pay no FBT at all on a novated lease. Every dollar — finance, charging, insurance, servicing — comes out pre-tax with no clawback. For someone in the 39% marginal bracket, that's roughly a third off the cost of the car. This exemption single-handedly explains why novated EV leasing exploded; note that plug-in hybrids lost the exemption for new leases from April 2025, and the rules have a sunset review — check currency before signing a 5-year term.

For petrol cars, the standard trick is the employee contribution method (ECM): you pay 20% of the car's value each year from post-tax salary, which cancels the FBT liability, and the rest comes out pre-tax. The benefit is real but much thinner — often only worth it for higher incomes and heavier running costs.

The traps the glossy quote glosses over

Rule of thumb from the maths above: EV + higher income = lease usually wins clearly. Petrol car + income under ~$90k = a good car loan is often cheaper once fees and the padded rate are counted. Make the provider beat the loan comparison, not the sticker price.

Frequently asked questions

Is a novated lease worth it?
For an FBT-exempt EV on a middle-to-high income, usually yes — savings of $15,000–$30,000 over five years versus a loan are realistic. For petrol cars the benefit is thinner and provider fees or a padded interest rate can wipe it out; compare against a loan every time.
What is the residual value on a novated lease?
The lump sum you pay at the end to own the car, set by ATO minimums — about 28% of the original cost after 5 years. GST applies when you pay it. You can refinance it, re-lease, or sell the car (keeping any surplus).
Why are EVs so much better on a novated lease?
Electric vehicles under the luxury car tax threshold are exempt from fringe benefits tax, so the entire package comes from pre-tax salary with no FBT clawback — the full marginal-rate saving flows to you.
What happens to my novated lease if I change jobs?
The salary deductions stop and you become personally liable for payments (from post-tax money) until you re-novate with a new employer. Factor in job stability before choosing a long term.
Does a novated lease affect my HECS or Medicare levy surcharge?
Yes — the packaged amount becomes a reportable fringe benefit, which counts toward HECS repayment income and surcharge thresholds even though it isn't taxed directly. High earners near the $250k Div 293 line should model this first.

Sources